Travel Duffel Bag: 3 Duffels with Backpack Straps Compared
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page earn us a small commission, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
Packing a travel duffel bag for a road trip can mean moving the same load between a room, a vehicle and a boat. Backpack straps help with those changes, but the choice also depends on how much space and organisation you need. This guide focuses on soft gear bags. Travel backpacks already have their own guides at NomadsToolsLab.
Quick answer
Checked on 21 October 2026. Choose Patagonia for removable backpack straps and compact storage between trips, or Eagle Creek when you need room to expand. Choose NEMO when switching between duffel and tote carry matters more than having published weight and dimensions.
All 3 picks at a glance
Patagonia Black Hole Duffel 55L
The empty bag packs into its own side pocket between trips. Read more
Eagle Creek Migrate Duffel 60L
The seamless bathtub bottom adds water resistance for wet transfer points. Read more
NEMO Double Haul Duffel 55L
Zippered mesh pockets inside and out give smaller items dedicated places. Read more
How we compared them
The NomadsToolsLab team read the three maker pages on 21 October 2026 and checked each Amazon US page with a US address. The comparison covered volume, carry options, fabric and weight. Among these bags, only Eagle Creek lists an expanded volume, only Patagonia has fully removable backpack straps, and only NEMO converts into a tote.
Volume, carry options and fabric: what changes your choice
Extra volume is useful only if you need it. Eagle Creek gives you an expansion option, while Patagonia and NEMO list a single capacity.
The makers list different coated fabrics, but those descriptions alone do not establish which bag will last longest. Treat fabric specifications as part of the choice, alongside carry comfort and organisation.
The three duffels side by side
| Duffel | Volume | Backpack straps | Weight | Main fabric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patagonia Black Hole 55L | Volume: 55 L | Backpack straps: Padded, removable | Weight: 1180 g | Main fabric: 900D recycled polyester ripstop, TPU laminate |
| Eagle Creek Migrate 60L | Volume: 60 L (67 L expanded) | Backpack straps: Tuck-away | Weight: 1.1 kg | Main fabric: 900D recycled polyester TPU, 1680D base |
| NEMO Double Haul 55L | Volume: 55 L | Backpack straps: Padded, tuck away | Weight: Not listed | Main fabric: 420D recycled nylon, urethane-coated |
From the makers' pages, read on 21 October 2026: Patagonia, Eagle Creek and NEMO.
Patagonia Black Hole Duffel: removable straps and compact storage
Patagonia Black Hole Duffel 55L
Pick the Patagonia Black Hole Duffel 55L if you want backpack carry during transfers and removable shoulder straps afterward. You can take them off completely, but Switchback Travel and CleverHiker note limited structure and few organising pockets.
The side pocket also holds the empty bag, which gives it a defined storage place between trips. If you prefer a bag that holds its shape while you pack, the reviewers' comments are worth considering.
Eagle Creek Migrate Duffel: space for a changing load
Eagle Creek Migrate Duffel 60L
Pick the Eagle Creek Migrate Duffel 60L if your load changes during a trip, because it provides extra packing room when expanded. The tradeoff is carrying comfort, with Bettertrail finding the handles and backpack straps uncomfortable over longer carries.
Its backpack straps tuck away when you switch carry styles. The maker describes water resistance and a seamless bathtub bottom, but that does not establish waterproof protection.
NEMO Double Haul Duffel: a tote option for gear runs
NEMO Double Haul Duffel 55L
Pick the NEMO Double Haul Duffel 55L if gear runs call for tote-style carry, because its tote handles offer another way to move the load. The limitation is planning around size and weight, since NEMO lists neither dimensions nor weight.
The padded backpack straps tuck into their own space when you use the tote handles. CleverHiker notes floppy sides when empty and no side grab handles, so consider how you prefer to lift and pack a loaded bag.
Choose around the transfers your trip involves
For road trips and long stays, decide whether you value packing the empty bag away or adding space as your load changes. Patagonia addresses the first need, while Eagle Creek addresses the second.
For gear runs, NEMO adds a tote option. If your route includes long walking transfers, give the reported carry limitations particular attention before choosing. Prefer a backpack? See our Osprey Farpoint vs Fairview and Peak Design vs Nomatic comparisons.
- Patagonia lets you remove the backpack straps completely and stow the empty bag in its side pocket.
- Eagle Creek is the only option here with a listed expanded capacity.
- NEMO is the only option here that converts from duffel to tote.
- Choose for your actual load and transfer routine. Capacity alone leaves out comfort, access and organisation.
Watch: the Black Hole duffel up close
BAG & TRAVEL compares the Patagonia Black Hole with The North Face Base Camp in its 2026 video. It offers context beyond the three bags covered here.
Video by BAG & TRAVEL.
See the Patagonia Black Hole 55L on Amazon.
Backcountry's 2023 video, “Go-Anywhere Bag: Patagonia Black Hole 55L Duffel,” focuses on the Patagonia option. Use it alongside the maker specifications discussed above.
Video by Backcountry.
See the Patagonia Black Hole 55L on Amazon.
FAQ
Which travel duffel bag here expands?
The Eagle Creek Migrate expands from 60 L to 67 L. It is the only bag in this comparison with a second, expanded capacity listed by its maker.
Which bag has completely removable backpack straps?
The Patagonia Black Hole has padded backpack straps that come off completely. The Eagle Creek and NEMO straps tuck away instead.
Are these duffels waterproof?
The makers' pages do not establish that any of these bags is waterproof. Eagle Creek describes its Migrate as water resistant with a seamless bathtub bottom.
Which duffel converts into a tote?
The NEMO Double Haul converts from duffel to tote using its tote handles. Its padded backpack straps tuck into their own space when you use another carry style.
Affiliate disclosure. This post contains affiliate links. If you click and buy something, this site earns a small commission at no extra cost to you. Picks are based on published specs, independent tests and manufacturer information. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read the full affiliate disclosure. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
Your next step
